Writers’ Club Blood Bath


I decided if I was going to take my writing seriously, and eventually make more than a hobby out of it, I better get used to sharing my work with strangers, and so I recently took the plunge and found a local writer’s club.

It was a small group, only two of us submitting work to be critiqued – one of them being mine.

I’ve worked tirelessly on this first chapter. As many of you can relate, it’s my baby. It’s the beginning, the conception, the dawn, the inception even, of dreams, goals, successes and failures – my writing journey.

And so, as I sat at the head of the table, under the “cone of silence” for 20 minutes while the group critiqued my work, it felt like they were calling my newborn baby ugly.

Most had kind things to say, with constructive criticism that I could actually use to put towards helping “my baby” develop. One person in particular (we will call him Mr. middle aged metro sexual) had just awful critical and judgmental things to say.

I scribbled away, taking as many notes as possible to reflect later and re-edit. But, I couldn’t help thinking, wondering, how much of this critique was actually good advice? After all, “Mr. middle-aged metro sexual” hasn’t submitted any work, ever, to the group. How do I know how good his advice is? Does he know what he is talking about, or does he just get his rocks off on bringing others around him down? In the same seat as myself, never published, at the infancy of writing, what makes his opinion valid?

Overall, I took away many positive attributes from the group.

#1: It is a safe place to share my work

#2: It’s un-biased, which is always a plus

#3: Networking, networking, networking

#4: It was really fun to talk to like-minded people and score a few writing tips

#5: The thickness of my skin grew a little, even if it was difficult to take some of it.

Overall, I will go to the meeting again in 3 weeks. I won’t be submitting this time, just taking in others’ work and critiquing. I will be careful, not to add to any of the blood splashed across the coffee house floor. I plan to be delicate but helpful – coddling their baby but insisting it needs a bath if need be…


Posted by

We read to learn, to feel, to laugh, to understand others. We write to teach, express, communicate, to inspire others. I created Invisible Ink as an outlet of sorts, an area where I can organize the chaos; a place where hopefully I can be true to myself, and my readers. Writing is personal, it takes a brave and dedicated soul to formulate a piece and then share it with the world. That being said, I get just as much out of reading other's work as I do sharing mine ( I am always open to manuscript review swaps, just send me a message). Words read off a page evoke emotions. When taken out of context, or through an out of focus lens - anyone can mold the words, shifting their meaning to fit their agenda or distorted outlook. Staying true to form and myself, I won't censor my content, but I will censor my audience. Whatever lens you happen to be reading this through - I hope you enjoy!

4 thoughts on “Writers’ Club Blood Bath

  1. Oh, I’m so sorry for the hurt. In the past, I’ve tried listening to those who said, “Take what you need and leave the rest behind,” but it didn’t make the insensitive comments less painful. I admire your courage, though. Perhaps at some point an evening class — with an experienced teacher who can manage the oafs in the room? Leslie

    1. Thanks for the advice! Being a first timer, I wasn’t sure how much to take away.I definitely got some things I needed out of the meeting though, so all in all, it was a great experience!

  2. Thanks for the reply Elaine – good stuff! It actually went into my email and titled “do not reply” I will try to see if I can post it back on here. That strategy seems to be useful, that way everyone knows what is coming, and what to remember when writing.

I'd love to hear your thoughts!

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s